I normally wouldn't post such seemingly-mundane things as top-10 lists on this blog. Each day, gamefaqs.com posts a top-10 list submitted by members of the gamefaqs community. Most of them are highly opinionated and therefore not worth much attention. For example, a list of "top 10" RPGs ends up coming from some niche: maybe a devoted Final Fantasy VII fan, or a console RPG purist, or a WoW addict, etc. This one, however, is genuinely unique: "Top 10 Blockbuster games that split opinions" looks at some of the most popular games and outlines the debates surrounding them. Since all of these games have a huge fanbase, it is very interesting to read how people have criticized them over the years.
Some highlights include games that have been mentioned before on this blog: the MGS series, Kingdom Hearts series, and The Legend of Zelda. A surprise (mostly because I had forgotten about it) is Chrono Cross.
I encourage you to check out the reviews of any of these games on the site and read some of the arguments in more depth.